Free Consultation
(314) 500-HURTCan you submit a case to a jury on two different legal
theories?
Q: Do you have to elect your remedy before going to the jury?
A: Sometimes
Typically, you do have to elect your remedy and submit one legal theory for each claim of damages before going to a
jury. Courts don’t want double recovery or inconsistent verdicts.
However, a plaintiff may submit two different legal theories for the same injury so long as: 1) the theories are not
factually or legally inconsistent, i.e. proof of one theory does not disprove the other; and 2) the theories do not
permit the jury to award a double recovery. Whittom v. Alexander-Richardson
Partnership, et al., 851 S.W.2d 504 (Mo. banc 1993).
In a case we tried two weeks ago, we submitted the case on two theories: 1) that the psychiatrist Dr.
Mattingly committed medical negligence which resulted in the death of his patient and others, and 2) a legal theory
under famous cases Tarasoff
v. Regents of Univ. of Cal., 17 Cal.3d 425 (Cal. 1976), and Bradley
v. Ray, 904 S.W.2d 302 (Mo.App. W.D. 1995), where because Dr. Mattingly knew or should have known of the risk of
danger his patient presented to others, he was negligent in failing to warn them of that danger.
Because these two theories are not inconsistent (proof of medical negligence would not disprove failure to warn, and
vice versa), and because we were only seeking one remedy (wrongful death damages), we were able to submit both legal
theories to the jury.
An illustration in MAI guided us. Illustration 35.15 shows how you can submit two verdict directors and one verdict form
to avoid multiple recoveries for the same injury. So, you structure your verdict directors so that the jury can elect
two different liability theories but just have one amount of damages to assess.
We effectively did this by organizing our verdict form in three parts. Part I asked the jury to determine liability only
on our medical negligence claim. Part II asked the jury to determine liability only on our failure to warn claim. Part
III required the jury to determine the total amount of damages, which would be the same for either (or both!) claims.
The jury was free to elect one or both theories of liability. Email me if you’d like a set of the instructions we used.
Submitting two different legal theories can give the plaintiff an advantage, because some jurors may resonate more with
one theory than the other. The way we structured our verdict form alleviated the concern of a double recovery (which
would lead to possible error), and also enabled us to determine which theory(ies) the jury relied on in the event of an
appeal.
Other examples where you can submit two theories to obtain one recovery include:
In contrast, examples where you cannot submit two theories:
Founder | Injury Attorney
Gary Burger has dedicated his career to standing up against bullies. The founder and principal attorney of Burger Law | St. Louis Personal Injury Lawyer has helped hundreds of Missouri and Illinois individuals and families recover th …
Years of experience: 30 years
Location: St. Louis, MO
Similar Blog Posts
So What if You Have a Bad Insurance Experience? You pay for insurance to manage the numerous risks of driving, owning a house, or many other things. Based on the advertisements an...
Perjury occurs when a person makes a statement under oath while they know it is not the truth. Most perjury cases in Missouri happen when a witness tells a lie related to an invest...
When a personal injury attorney accepts a case, they intend to complete a claim and achieve the best possible outcome. Even so, circumstances often change, forcing an attorney to w...
521 W. Main Street Suite 201 O
Belleville, IL 62220
By appointment only
(618) 500-4878 GET DIRECTIONS332 S Michigan Ave Suite 900
Chicago, IL 60604
By appointment only
(312) 500-HURT GET DIRECTIONS100 Chesterfield Business Pkwy Suites 200-222
Chesterfield, MO 63005
By appointment only
(314) 648-8348 GET DIRECTIONSNO FEES UNTIL WE WIN YOUR CASE
We offer free consultations and are available 24/7 to take your call. Live chat, text, and virtual meetings are available.
or call us at
(314) 500-HURT