Free Consultation
(314) 500-HURTThe preponderance of the evidence is the burden of proof standard in most civil and tort cases. To demonstrate a preponderance of the evidence, and thereby win a civil case, a plaintiff must convince a trier of fact that the defendant is more likely than not to be liable for the plaintiff’s damages. In other words, that there is a greater than 50 percent chance that the events occurred as the plaintiff alleges.
The preponderance standard differs from the beyond a reasonable doubt standard in criminal cases, where a jury must be convinced there is no other reasonable explanation for the crimes. In the late 1700s, lawyers and legal theorists began to question if civil cases, in the name of justice, really merited such a high burden as beyond reasonable doubt. In an 1801 criminal case in Delaware, State v. Crocker, a judge instructed the jury: Presumptive evidence, where there is a concurrence of circumstances convincing the jury, is sufficient. In civil cases a preponderance of evidence is sufficient for you to convict; in criminal, you should have proof.
Previously, jurors were told to “give a verdict as your consciences direct you,” or base their judgment on what they “think” or “believe.” After the preponderance standard was introduce in the late 1700s, the idea slowly picked up steam and became the law of the land for civil cases. As the Pennsylvania summarized in Karch v. Karch, 885 A.2d 535 (2005):
preponderance of the evidence is defined as the greater weight of the evidence, i.e., to tip a scale slightly is the criteria or requirement for preponderance of the evidence.
For example, in a car accident claim, you would only need to convince the jury, judge or mediator that the other party probably caused your injuries. This can be achieved through photographs, eye witness depositions, police reports and testimony from expert witnesses. In a slip and fall case, the fact finder would need to believe that the property owner likely should have known of the dangerous condition that injured you.
Client Reviews
This law firm is absolutely amazing. They took on my case, when nobody else would! They fought hard for me when it seemed there was no hope. They kept me informed and always asked for my input before making decisions on my case. Gary puts himself into every case unlike most law firm owners. Gary and his team really care about every one of their clients, and fights hard to get you a fair settlement. They actually won my case out of court, and then reduced my fees to make sure I could get my car fixed and be able to get back to some normality. I would recommend Burger Law over and above any other firm! If you go somewhere else you aren’t getting the best!
View More Reviews on Google Maps and Yelp
521 W. Main Street Suite 201 O
Belleville, IL 62220
By appointment only
(618) 500-4878 GET DIRECTIONS332 S Michigan Ave Suite 900
Chicago, IL 60604
By appointment only
(312) 500-HURT GET DIRECTIONS100 Chesterfield Business Pkwy Suites 200-222
Chesterfield, MO 63005
By appointment only
(314) 648-8348 GET DIRECTIONSNO FEES UNTIL WE WIN YOUR CASE
We offer free consultations and are available 24/7 to take your call. Live chat, text, and virtual meetings are available.
or call us at
(314) 500-HURT