Category: Car Accidents

$47,106.50 Plaintiff Verdict in Disputed Liability Soft Tissue Auto Case

Get a Free Consultation Or call (314) 648-8348

$47,106.50 Plaintiff Verdict in Disputed Liability Soft Tissue Auto Case

Jury trials are back, and we are still winning! Genavieve Fikes recently won a two-day jury trial in St. Clair County, Illinois, before Judge Heinz Rudolf. The case involved a disputed-liability intersection collision at Route 159 and Highway 15 in Belleville, Illinois, in August of 2017.

Following the collision, Plaintiff went to the emergency room and was x-rayed and diagnosed with a contusion from the seatbelt and arthritis. Her primary care doctor later diagnosed her with a neck and back strain resulting from the collision and referred her to two months of physical therapy.

Plaintiff incurred $17,106.50 in related medical charges, the bulk of which was hospital and imaging.

Despite Defendant's admission in her deposition that she had a stop sign on Highway 15 and that Plaintiff had the right-of-way for nearly three years, Allstate only offered Plaintiff $8,369.00 to settle her case, which was only about half of her medical bills.

As such, Burger Law geared up for the trial and took the depositions of Plaintiff's doctor and the defendant's paid expert, Dr. Richard Lehman. Before trial, in response to Plaintiff's bottom-line demand of $40,000, Allstate finally increased their offer to $20,909. This offer was obviously not enough to compensate Plaintiff for her injuries, medical expenses, loss of everyday life experienced, and pain and suffering.

So, the parties went to trial in St. Clair County, Illinois. Because of Covid, the panel for jury selection only consisted of 21 potential jurors, and only 6 jurors and 1 alternate ultimately heard the case.

Genavieve was able to get 1/3 of the jury panel struck for cause based on information that she could elicit from the potential jurors showing bias.

The Trial

At trial, Defendant and Allstate refused to accept responsibility for the collision and asserted that Plaintiff was contributorily negligent for not avoiding the crash or maintaining control of her vehicle. They minimized her cervical and thoracic strains as "whiplash" and tried to invalidate her pain and suffering. They highlighted Plaintiff's arthritis and negative imaging to try to diminish her damages.

Through cross-examination of Defendant on the stand with her deposition testimony, Genavieve was able to catch Defendant in her "prior inconsistent statements." (ahem…lies). Plaintiff testified about the accident's impact on her life and stood up well to defense counsel's cross-examination.

The Verdict

Ultimately, the jury returned a verdict in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant for $47,106.50, which comprised $17,106.50 in past medical expenses, $10,000 for loss of everyday life experienced, and $20,000 for pain and suffering.

This is Genavieve's third disputed-liability jury trial victory in cases defended specifically by Allstate.

Genavieve 3 – Allstate 0.

It was a four-year-long fight against Allstate, but Burger Law never gave up.

Request a Free Consultation

“Gary and his team provided us with effective, efficient and highly professional service. Gary provides sound advice and is a trustworthy and ethical attorney. I highly recommend the team!”

David and Fran Schneider

Hurt? Hire Us Today or call (314) 648-8348

We Deliver Great Results

Over $170 Million won for our clients

$5,000,000 Settlement - Father Killed by Reckless Truck Driver

$5 Million

Personal Injury Lawyer, Gary Burger and Burger Law represented a family of a man killed ...

View Wrongful Death Result

Multi-Car Crash Caused by Debris from Commercial Truck - $2,000,000 Settlement

$2 Million

The St. Louis area personal injury attorneys at Burger Law represented a woman who swerved ...

View Truck Accident Result

Injured Woman Settles Highway Crash Lawsuit - $2,000,000 Settlement

$2 Million

In addition to the above case, you need to be creative in finding insurance in ...

View Truck Accident Result

Truck Accident - $1,000,000 Settlement

$1 Million

In this case, a reckless driver struck and killed a tow truck driver who was ...

View Car Accident Result

$765,000 Settlement After Fatal Collision


We fought on behalf of Amy Van Doren and her children when her husband was ...

View Wrongful Death Result

$765,000 Settlement


We represent Paul’s family. He tragically died last year. He was traveling with his wife ...

View Wrongful Death Result

View More Results

Common Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

The success of your personal injury claim depends on many factors and a lot goes into determining the value of your case. Get a better understanding of what to expect and what you can do through our answers to some of the most common questions we hear from injury victims and their families.

View all FAQs

What Tricks Do Insurance Companies Use To Avoid Paying Claims?

When you have a personal injury claim, be aware of the tricks insurance companies will use to try to avoid paying claims like yours. While there are some occasions where the defendant's insurance company will act in good faith and offer a fair settlement without extensive litigation, it is more co …

View Full Answer

Leading Causes of Car Accidents

The most common causes of accidents among motor vehicles such as trucks, cars, and motorcycles are not attributed to environmental conditions outside of our control, but to driver error. A car accident can occur at any time, but understanding other drivers' behavior and the most common factors tha …

View Full Answer

View all FAQs