Category: Car Accidents

Two great settlements on the eve of trial

Get a Free Consultation Or call (314) 648-8348

On Saturday, I settled Mary's car crash case against Allstate. We were scheduled to go to trial yesterday. Mary was injured in a 2017 car crash. The offer was $21,000 until about 4:30 on Friday afternoon when Allstate capitulated and paid the $100,000 policy limits.

And yes, I work on Saturdays.

This often happens in my practice. The client and I decide the value of the case and then we keep going until the other side realizes the wisdom of our position. Often, the only power an injured person has is a trial against the wrongdoer's insurance company.

We took the medical doctor's depositions by video tape and filed our full pretrial with the court. We argued the motions on Friday and were ready to go. The courthouse closed because of a winter storm and the judge kept the Motion hearing on schedule by doing them from his home on a conference call.

After winning the key motions and insisting on the accurate value of the case we got what Mary deserved.

In the second case, my great coworker Genavieve obtained a $90,000 settlement in a car accident case for her client Jamal where there was only $4,500.00 in medical billing charges. Sometimes, the low cost of medical bills does not reflect the severity of our client’s injuries.

Here, Jamal suffered a small labral tear in his right shoulder in a crash that happened like this:

He treated conservatively with physical therapy and injections. An orthopedic surgeon opined that an arthroscopic surgery would not be unreasonable for him to consider if he continued to have persistent pain and weakness.

However, the surgeon informed Jamal that the recovery process after such a surgery could take up to a year. Jamal works in a job that requires him to use his arm and shoulder. He already missed five weeks of work. Jamal ultimately decided to forego having the surgery, but he might go forward with it in the future.

In a situation like this, where a client has a serious injury but low medical bills, it is extremely important to add value to the case by highlighting other factors.

Here, Genavieve emphasized that this was a high speed collision on the highway, Jamal’s car was totaled, and objective evidence showed a labral tear.

In addition to the $4,500 in medical charges and $4,800 in lost wages already incurred by Jamal, Genavieve estimated the cost of a future arthroscopic labral repair ($27,171.00), anesthesia ($5,424.00), post-surgical physical therapy ($15,572.43), and future lost wages ($4,000 - $20,000). Suddenly, Jamal’s economic damages increased from $9k to ~$60k-$80k.

The policy limits in the case were $100,000. Genavieve sent a bad faith letter pursuant to RSMo. § 573.058, demanding the $100,000 limits.

Insurance companies are often hesitant to consider future medical or future lost wages, claiming they are speculative. But if they don’t consider them, and a jury does, they run the risk of getting an excess judgment at trial.

Likewise, Jamal ran the risk of going to trial with only $9,000.00 in actual damages, being cross-examined about why he had not had the surgery, and a jury disregarding the future medical and future lost wages.

As we approached trial, the insurance company offered $90,000 which we happily accepted.

Request a Free Consultation


“Gary and his team provided us with effective, efficient and highly professional service. Gary provides sound advice and is a trustworthy and ethical attorney. I highly recommend the team!”

David and Fran Schneider

Hurt? Hire Us Today or call (314) 648-8348

We Deliver Great Results

Over $170 Million won for our clients


$5,000,000 Settlement - Father Killed by Reckless Truck Driver

$5 Million


Personal Injury Lawyer, Gary Burger and Burger Law represented a family of a man killed ...

View Wrongful Death Result

$3 Million Judgment - Son Murdered by Pam Hupp

$3 Million


$3 Million Judgment. Gary Burger represented Margaret Burch, the mother of murder victim Louis Gumpenberger. ...

View Wrongful Death Result

$2.5 Million Settlement for Father's Fatal Car Accident

$2.5 Million


$2.5 Million Wrongful Death Settlement For Daughters of Fatal Car Accident Victim Gary Burger of ...

View Wrongful Death Result

Multi-Car Crash Caused by Debris from Commercial Truck - $2,000,000 Settlement

$2 Million


The St. Louis area personal injury attorneys at Burger Law represented a woman who swerved ...

View Truck Accident Result

Injured Woman Settles Highway Crash Lawsuit - $2,000,000 Settlement

$2 Million


In addition to the above case, you need to be creative in finding insurance in ...

View Truck Accident Result

$1.435 Million Settlement Against Three Defendants After Extensive Litigation

$1.4 Million


Gary represented the Macharias and settled the case for $1.435 million against three parties after ...

View Premise Liability Result

View More Results

Common Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

The success of your personal injury claim depends on many factors and a lot goes into determining the value of your case. Get a better understanding of what to expect and what you can do through our answers to some of the most common questions we hear from injury victims and their families.

View all FAQs

How To Choose The Right Personal Injury Lawyer For Me

How do you determine which personal injury lawyer is right for you? As you've undoubtedly heard the disclaimer at the end of TV and radio commercials for law firms: the choice of a lawyer is important and should not be based solely upon advertisements. The key is to speak with the lawyer and de …

View Full Answer

How Long Do I Have to File a Personal Injury Claim?

Do you know how long you have to file a personal injury claim? Or when the best time is to file one? Is it better to do it immediately after your accident or to wait until you know how significantly your injuries have affected your life? These are just the beginning of the string of questions t …

View Full Answer

What Tricks Do Insurance Companies Use To Avoid Paying Claims?

When you have a personal injury claim, be aware of the tricks insurance companies will use to try to avoid paying claims like yours. While there are some occasions where the defendant's insurance company will act in good faith and offer a fair settlement without extensive litigation, it is more co …

View Full Answer

View all FAQs

Schema