Here's a scary story with Halloween coming up. Our client Roy goes to Wal-Mart on May 20, 2016, for new eyeglasses, He sees Dr. Kenton McWilliams and complains his left eye is painful and tearing,

McWilliams treats Plaintiff with steroid eye drops without doing a diagnostic culture. Roy’s condition gets worse - blurry vision, watering, severe pain and pressure, and light sensitivity.

A few weeks later, Roy sought treatment from another doctor who performed appropriate diagnostic testing and determined that Plaintiff had a staphylococcus infection for which antibiotics were necessary and steroid drops were harmful.

His eye had become really red:

After his treatment, Roy was left with greatly diminished vision in his left eye and sensitivity to light.

We filed suit and did depositions in the case.

We tried to show that Dr. McWilliams breached the standard of care by failing to properly diagnose Mr. Payne, by prescribing Neo Poly Dex, and failing to rule out contraindicated diagnoses (including, but not limited to, fungal infections). If you put steroids in a fungal infection its like putting gas on a fire.

What started out as a likely corneal abrasion and eye infection spiraled into a large corneal ulcer with permanent scarring and vision loss.

My Deposition of McWilliams went well - he did not even have a diagnosis when he prescribed the medication. Here are some excerpts:

Q: And then what did you diagnose him with?

A: Well, I wasn’t sure what it was. So it looked like a recurrent corneal erosion. And I have a question mark.

Q: So then what did you decide to do?

A: I don’t – I think I explained to him there’s something going on, but I’m not sure what it is. I don’t know if I explained the term recurrent corneal erosions because typically I don’t explain that under those terms.

It does not take an expert to understand that in order to properly treat a condition, you have to know what the condition is. McWilliams didn't.

And the standard of care when prescribing Neo Poly Dex drops requires that an optometrist rule out contraindicated diagnoses, otherwise further damage to the eye, such as corneal ulcers and scarring, can occur.

Q: So it is the standard of care to rule those corneal, fungal and viral out before you prescribe it; is that correct?

A: Generally speaking, yes.

Q: And you did not rule those out prior to making the prescription that you did, fair?

A: I would say that’s fair in any case, but yes.

Q: Isn’t a – aren’t you supposed to check for a fungus infection before you prescribe that medication?

A: Or at least rule it out.

Q: Did you rule it out?

A: I couldn’t really rule out anything at that point.

Dr. McWilliams had to admit that:

A. Typically if you suspect fungal you wouldn’t prescribe it. If you suspect corneal viral, especially herpes, you wouldn’t want to prescribe it.

Roy kindly did a video with me:

Dr. McWilliams also breached the standard of care by failing to schedule a follow up appointment with Mr. Payne to monitor his condition.

Q: Is it important to, if you’re giving someone an antibiotic with a steroid, to do close monitoring of his condition thereafter?

A: I would agree.

Later I asked:

Q: So you did not tell him to come back in seven days. You told him to take the medication for seven days, correct?

A: Yes.

McWilliams had to admit:

Q: What would you have done differently, knowing the history?

A: Knowing all the history and his visits to the second, third, and fourth doctors I probably would have referred his case right away.

Q: Meaning when he first came to you?

A: Had I known how bad it potentially could have been I would have referred him to a corneal specialist.

Q: So are you saying you would have referred him to a specialist, May 20, the day you saw him, had you known everything in hindsight, or are you saying that had he called you back you would have referred him?

A: Both.

Not surprisingly:

Q: Did you have complaints about patients – from patients about the care they received?

A: I would say occasionally.

We settled the case for $200,000. There were notes in the medical records that Roy's vision was not significantly diminished and he did take some time before he went and got additional medical care.

Request a Free Consultation

“Gary and his team provided us with effective, efficient and highly professional service. Gary provides sound advice and is a trustworthy and ethical attorney. I highly recommend the team!”

David and Fran Schneider

Hurt? Hire Us Today or call (314) 648-8348

We Deliver Great Results

Over $170 Million won for our clients

$5,000,000 Settlement - Father Killed by Reckless Truck Driver

$5 Million

Personal Injury Lawyer, Gary Burger and Burger Law represented a family of a man killed ...

View Wrongful Death Result

$3 Million Judgment - Son Murdered by Pam Hupp

$3 Million

$3 Million Judgment. Gary Burger represented Margaret Burch, the mother of murder victim Louis Gumpenberger. ...

View Wrongful Death Result

$2.5 Million Settlement for Father's Fatal Car Accident

$2.5 Million

$2.5 Million Wrongful Death Settlement For Daughters of Fatal Car Accident Victim Gary Burger of ...

View Wrongful Death Result

Multi-Car Crash Caused by Debris from Commercial Truck - $2,000,000 Settlement

$2 Million

The St. Louis area personal injury attorneys at Burger Law represented a woman who swerved ...

View Truck Accident Result

Injured Woman Settles Highway Crash Lawsuit - $2,000,000 Settlement

$2 Million

In addition to the above case, you need to be creative in finding insurance in ...

View Truck Accident Result

$1.435 Million Settlement Against Three Defendants After Extensive Litigation

$1.4 Million

Gary represented the Macharias and settled the case for $1.435 million against three parties after ...

View Premise Liability Result

View More Results

Common Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

The success of your personal injury claim depends on many factors and a lot goes into determining the value of your case. Get a better understanding of what to expect and what you can do through our answers to some of the most common questions we hear from injury victims and their families.

View all FAQs

How To Choose The Right Personal Injury Lawyer For Me

How do you determine which personal injury lawyer is right for you? As you've undoubtedly heard the disclaimer at the end of TV and radio commercials for law firms: the choice of a lawyer is important and should not be based solely upon advertisements. The key is to speak with the lawyer and de …

View Full Answer

How Long Do I Have to File a Personal Injury Claim?

Do you know how long you have to file a personal injury claim? Or when the best time is to file one? Is it better to do it immediately after your accident or to wait until you know how significantly your injuries have affected your life? These are just the beginning of the string of questions t …

View Full Answer

What Tricks Do Insurance Companies Use To Avoid Paying Claims?

When you have a personal injury claim, be aware of the tricks insurance companies will use to try to avoid paying claims like yours. While there are some occasions where the defendant's insurance company will act in good faith and offer a fair settlement without extensive litigation, it is more co …

View Full Answer

View all FAQs